August 3, 2008
President Bush is projected to run up a national budget deficit of $482 billion, possibly a lot more. This is a fiscal conservative? In fact, the only president in the last 25 years to not only not run up a deficit, but to actually leave a surplus, was one of them thar "tax-and-spend" Democrats.
Brilliant! Finally my conservative local paper has some balance to it! Loved it and look forward to more of your work!
The Star? Actually, most people don't consider the Ventura County Star to be a conservative paper, and some folks think of us as on the liberal side. We run some conservative columns and cartoons, but these are to balance more liberal columns and cartoons.
Anyhow, thanks for the nice words on my work... feel free to explore this archive (you can see years' worth via the links on the right-hand side).
Wow! You've compressed a lot of data and information into just a few words, and very few images. Great cartoon.
May I use the cartoon in history and government classes?
I actually was able to balance my budget using Clinton's idea's. He dismantled out military and raised taxes to produce a surplus. I took the same approach. My kids no longer get lunch money and I sold the wood from our fence and doors. I have all kinds of extra money now. Hopefully nobody decides to fly a plane into my couch...
Ah yes, the old "Clinton dismantled the military" Fairy tale. Amazing the stories Americans will allow themselves to believe.
I would like to republish this with full linking and credit...what are your rules on that?
For Ed and jennica: please email me (firstname.lastname@example.org) with your specific idea of how, where and in what context you were planning to use my cartoon.
You've been dugg.
Also, I've reposted your cartoon with full credit and a link back. I hope that is ok, but please let me know if it isn't!
I'd rather be a tax and spend democrat than a BORROW AND SPEND REPUBLICAN.
This should be posted all over the country-nomore words, just this brilliant cartoon. CONGRATULATIONS!!!
Brilliant Cartoon. I've never seen anyone communicate these facts as clearly and precisely. The simple fact is that Republicans say one thing and do the exact opposite once in office. Their real objective---above all others---is to put as much money into the pockets of the very wealthy people who they hang out with and who fund their campaigns. And that's the source of these deficits every time the Republicans are in the White House.
Congratulations on a superb illustration of a fiscal truth.
Thanks for all the nice words, folks. You're also welcome to send a Letter to the Editor (link at right) so it can be seen beyond these blog comments.
Just a quibble, but what you're showing is only annual deficits, what is added to the federal debt in a single year. These number's don't count money borrowed from Social Security, so the increase in the debt is considerably worse.
The real issue is that the "fiscal conservatives" have added many trillions of dollars to the federal debt. A far more shocking picture.
Thanks for the illustration.
Mazel Tov on a great cartoon. The truth hurts!!!!!
I especiallly enjoyed the cartoon in today's paper.Why is it my Republican friends do not see that as clearly as you do? Thanks I will have to send them an e-mail with your site address so they can get anpther perspective.
Ev from Massachusetts
Steve; do you offer prints of your cartoons? If so, please let me know how I could order your August 3, 2008 work. Thanks,
Mike: Yes, sometimes I will do this. Please email me off-blog at email@example.com. Are you local to Ventura County?
Look at who was in control of Congress during those periods.
Re: Your "Fiscal Conservative" cartoon. I seem to recall that under Reagan and the Bushes there was a Democrat Congress, while under Bubba we had the "Contract with America" with Newt. Still a pox on both their parties. This is why I greatly prefer GRIDLOCK, so, neither can push through their crappy agendas. Attila Kerekes, Warwick, RI.
Can I get this as a poster? Thanks
Well, this says a mouthful!
awesome, awesome, awesome!!!! where do i buy the t-shirt?
'Checking it out in New York State--'Makes just as much sense (non-sense)!
lol @ people in here arguing results with a bunch of excuses.
Pretending like the 90's were horrible is so see-through. yeah, GOP...it was awful.
The economic prosperity in the 90's cannot be contributed to Bill Clinton any more than you can attribute the internet to Al Gore. The president can make suggestions, and that's it. He has no real say.
If you want to find the party responsible for the deficit reduction and economic boom of the 90's look no farther than Newt Gingrich and the Republican controlled House and Senate. Have any of you ever actually READ the Contract with America? Want to be a REAL history teacher Ed Darrell? Read them that, don't show them cartoons. Idiot.
Can SOMEONE please PLEASE talk about congress and thier freaking responsibilites in all of this!?!?!?!?
Please america... tell me who decides WHERE YOUR MONEY GOES?!?!?!?!?!?
Its not your president... he has the option to veto or ok....
so who asks???
Presidents are not near as damn important as our congress. Democracy was designed to be that way. So that many people, not ONE PERSON, could come to the best conclusions and create the best plans for all parties and citizens involved...
STICK IT TO THE MEN/WOMAN! ITs not 1 man... get smart, stupid.
If "The president can make suggestions" and "has no real say" then you should feel quite comfortable with Barack Obama being elected into such a do-nothing position.
And, as i recall, it wasn't congress that was clamoring to go into Iraq. Who was that again?
I believe the biggest mistake congress made there was not standing up to the president and saying "No!" to that costly mistake.
If republicans are so fiscally responsible where's the money coming from to pay for the war, anyway?
Bush's war. Bush tax rebates. Bush incentive checks. Cutting taxes. The government is hemorrhaging money that it doesn't have!!!
Which brings me to the only reason democrats can own the title "tax and spend" is because they are fiscally responsible and have to clean up the deficit sins incurred by republicans who are nothing but spend spend spend.
That's why the cartoon is so funny. Because it is so true.
I think democrats should turn the tables on the republicans and start funding the projects they want the same way the republicans do. Keep spending up the deficit - after all, there's an infinite amount of money off into the future.
Um, Clinton never actually ran a surplus. Look at the debt graph, it goes up every year.
This was a lie run through the media for some reason. Clinton was able to borrow money from social security and not consider it "debt". The full detailed explanation can be found here:
I went out to the www.letxa.com web site and read the article.
Using the same U.S. Treasury web site that the article sites, i calculated the following (using a spreadsheet);
R. Reagan spent up the national debt $1.6946337 trillion (8 years)
G.H.W. Bush spent up the national debt $1.462283 trillion (4 years)
B. Clinton spent up the national debt $1.742842 trillion (8 years)
G. W. Bush spent up the national debt $4.081737 trillion (7 years)
At first blush i found this a bit unsettling and then i charted the data. I wish i could insert the image in this blog.
It shows during the Reagan years a slight upward curve to the deficit which indicates that it is increasing year to year.
It shows a marked increase during G.H.W. Bush's term.
It shows a decreasing curve from year to year during Clinton's terms.
And finally a HUGE increase during G.W. Bush's term (which i don't even have the final year's data for).
Just a note to Canis and the others pointing out control of Congress:
Under Clinton: 1993-94 Democratic House/Senate, 1995-2000 GOP House/Senate
Under Bush: 2001-6 GOP House/Senate, 2007-8 Democratic House/Senate
There are arguments to tie politics to economics and arguments that distance the two, but if you're going to play the congressional card, you have to play it honestly. Clinton's economic programs were backed by the GOP Congress and, in turn, Clinton backed the Contract with America. Clinton also failed to veto deregulation, which is a large part of what got us into this mess to begin with and was proposed by a GOP congress. Bush ran this country into the ground for 6 years with a GOP, "yes-man" Congress, and has since stalled with a year and a half of a "do nothing" Democratic Congress...
So actually boiling it down to this cartoon makes more sense than bringing Congress into it; how relevant either are is up for debate.
Absolutely my favorite political cartoon so far. It appeared in the Nov-Dec '08 issue of the UAW magazine "Solidarity."
Clinton failed to veto deregulation; however, if you look at the numbers that bill was "veto-proof." But he should have still vetoed it.
Better to tax & spend and at least pay for what you do than to borrow & spend and leave my grandkids to pay for it.
Well, I agree with the view of many others that the Democrats and Republicans are essentially two factions of the same party, the differences are evident only when the two are side by side and no other views are out there for comparison.
Clinton and Obama are conservative, Reagan built up our military drasticly employing millions upon millions during our 2nd Great Depression following our very imprudent rejection of Nixon and his wise pro american policies, and re started the Cold War as the excuse, GHW Bush did a massive downsizing of the military and cancelled DOD contracts laying off millions and millions causing him to lose re election (it's the economy stupid), Clinton inherited the reduced military and reduced it some more but in 3 years tghe economy had turned around with oil at $15 a bbl since the end of the Gulf war stoking our economy. GW Bush got OPEC on the rise again from '98 forward and oil spikinfg up to close to $150 a bbl collasping the world economy plus major terrorist strikes on the USA....
But really there is small difference between neoliberal Republicans and neoliberal Democrats. The last real change was Nixon, the last visonary. He wanted National Health Insurence. He wanted to rid us of dependence on OPEC. He oppossed Rockefellers attempts at population controll, he created OSHA, NTSB, NHTSB, administered real and effective advancements in civil rights, so much more. But he was tossed and driven into exile in a virtual coup by the right wing faction who has ruled us since 1974- the Democrat/Republican Neoliberals.
"Better to tax & spend and at least pay for what you do than to borrow & spend and leave my grandkids to pay for it.
Posted by: Dinah Sparks "
You have Grandchildren, Dinah Sparks? How incredibly rare.
Cartoon Idea for someone ...
panel 1 ... group of children (all races) protesting
Panel 2 ...Jeanine Garofalo ... asking what are you children up to?
Panel 3 ... Children ... we are protesting our future tax burden.
Panel 4 ... Jeanine G ... Racist!
In actual truth, fiscal conservatism is not limited to Republicans. There are also centrist/moderate democrats that practice being "fiscally" conservative. Bill Clinton was one of those centrists. some of the most prominent points in his administration was NAFTA, reducing government spending and balancing the budget/reducing the national debt. The country was not out of debt during the Clinton years. but it was reduced. (lastly, the basic fundamentals of FISCAL conservatism is reducing government spending, reducing the national debt, and balancing the budget. Things that Clinton was able to do, since he was able to co-operate with the republican led Senate (of the time) The other times mentioned in the cartoon, how was inter-branch relationships at the time?
GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT!!!
Gee, another bald face lie from a liberal? Bill Clinton drove us into debt and never had a surplus. The media is full of it including Greenberg. We have been running on deficit for decades in this country. Bill Clinton was too busy bombing an aspirin factory in Libya to get the attention off his own scandal. Another failing comic, Steve Greenberg. You praise Bill Clinton, the same Billy Clinton who is guilty of perjury. stealing from the white house and falsely accusing others of nuclear weapon factories when doing no harm. Or how about the Bill Clinton that smoked marijuana but he didn't inhale??? Or how about the Bill Clinton who had Vince Foster killed because he was going to expose the Clinton's?
The best part about this cartoon is that it brings the Bush apologists to the surface. regardless of who was in congress "W" acted more unilateraly than any president in the history of the USA. he did what he wanted, when he wanted, with whose-ever money he wanted, period. That was the republican positive point 0 they claimed sokmething would finally get done with "W" in office - too bad they were right......
"Posted by: Ed Darrell at August 5, 2008 1:45 PM
I actually was able to balance my budget using Clinton's idea's. He dismantled out military and raised taxes to produce a surplus. I took the same approach. My kids no longer get lunch money and I sold the wood from our fence and doors. I have all kinds of extra money now. Hopefully nobody decides to fly a plane into my couch..."
My Christian name is Carol Bryant and I live in Port St. Lucie, Illinois.
I have been trying quite some various dating blogs to attempt and search for a soul mate. I finally suprisingly found this website and there is alot help and I finally found my special soul mate! Here is the link: http://www.loveblogspot.com/
Hope you uncover someone also, Carol!
Could you make a cartoon of chicken little in the background, and the big bird dressed up in a gop outfit feeding chicks , with a pile of feed next to them called propaganda fear, hate, racism, facism, and hero elect written on the zipper suit of the gop showing under the zipper of the big bird feeding all the chicks mouths open to the sky...
the meaning is same ol same ol, with chicken lil, and the rest is self explanatory of feeding fear of helpless ness to say they will get re elected victim of society propaganda is fear, hate and racism compared to inspiration... thanks..Henry.
Wow, fantastic blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is fantastic, as well as the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Wow, incredible blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is fantastic, as well as the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Wow, awesome blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is fantastic, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Wow, awesome blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is wonderful, as well as the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Wow, fantastic blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is excellent, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Wow, superb blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is excellent, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Actually great website! Have you got any tips for future writers? I hope to start out my extremely own website just before lengthy but I am considerably lost upon almost anything.
Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is magnificent, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
I am not sure where you are getting your info, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for magnificent information I was looking for this Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star for my mission.
I'll check your brand-new revise, this is extremely information.
This is truly useful, a lot of thanks for publishing
At any rate, I discovered this particular subject when you use CURL to acquire world wide web pages.
Just gained any symbol new viewer
Wow, superb blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is excellent, as well as the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Wow, superb blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is fantastic, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Blogs: Steve Greenberg's Cartoons / Ventura County Star .
Which is nearly all genuinely new to myself which post genuinely exposed my own eye.Thank you for revealing in addition to us the perception.
Excellent capturing emotions in these!
I can continue with our investigation basically by dealing with your weblog post.
i wonder a few factors i ought to do
The content articles is essentially fantastic : N. Very good job, regards
Hello, i really feel that i located you went to our net site i truly stumbled on ?come back the favor?
Good day! I just want to give an enormous thumbs up for
the nice data you could have right here on this post.
I will likely be coming again to your blog for more soon.
Great post. You made some good points.