Login | Member Center | Contact Us | Site Map | Archives | Alerts | Subscribe to the paper

HomeBlogsNo Issues Left Behind

« High School & College Standards |  Main  | Arleigh's Army »

April 02, 2005

Faux Gun Fire Helps Nobody

School shootings are in the news again, and they are unbelievable and incomprehensable tragedies for the victims, students, families and communities. Indeed, when something like what happened in Minnesota in March happens on a public school campus, it's a tragedy for our nation.

With open lines of communication though, many such incidents are avoided when kids take the responsibility to go to authorities and alert them to such plans. This is a good thing, and the reality is that last year there were 3,000 gun-related deaths in the U.S. last year, but just 1 percent happened on school campuses.

This brings me to a concern I have about recent activities in Ventura, and I want your suggestions about what can or should be done in the future. According to an article in the April 2 Ventura County Star, Ventura School Officials decided recently to have "lockdown drills" at high school and middle school campuses. Ordinarily these drills are begun with a bell ringing or some other alarm.

The Ventura drills started with gunfire, coming from guns on campus, and adminstrators firing them with blanks. Um... YIKES!

Needless to say, kids were scared by the gunfire, made to feel uncomfortable - Many even ran. A police officer across the street from one of the campuses even heard the gunfire and saw kids running. This officer did not know about the drill!

Is this kind of drill, with blanks being fired, really necessary? Helping kids to understand the situation and what to do in the event of an emergency is one thing, but simulating an emergency with faux gunfire is quite another.

When traveling, we're taught before the place takes off how to get out, or what to do in the event of an emergency. They don't simulate crashing the plane just to make sure we're paying attention!

Ojai Superintendent Tim Baird said it best:

"We would never simulate something like that," Baird said. "You don't practice a fire drill in a crowded room by screaming, 'fire.' ... It needs to be real ... but you don't want panic."

Right....

What say you?


Comments

I'm shocked that Ventura Unified would allow this drill to take place! And the fact that a VC Police officer nearby heard the shots and was unaware of the drill makes this story all the more disturbing! Shame on Ventura Unified!

Has Simi Unified considered undertaking such drills? Is this type of decision subject to a hearing at School Board meetings? Can the individual schools make the call on this?

While I understand these drills are necessary in preparing students, is it necessary to scare the you-know-what out of them? I say not. Can you say, "intentional infliction of emotional distress?" Lawyers can, and do!

As of this posting, there are 17 comments on The Star's web site on the April 2nd article. Some in favor, and some against this idea (and some just CRAZY!).

Posted by: Francisco at April 4, 2005 02:30 PM
Post a comment






Remember personal info?






Sponsored Links