Unions keep immigrants out

Share: Share on Facebook submit to reddit StumbleUpon Toolbar

Re: U.S. Rep. Elton Gallegly’s July 23 commentary, “Take away welcome mat for illegal immigrants�:

Rep. Gallegly noted all the things that attract illegal immigrants to our country.

The very first item was employment. Yet, he completely ignored this issue in the remainder of his essay. This should come as no surprise. Each election year, the biggest Gallegly campaign signs show up first on local farmland. We cannot expect real solutions to this problem from a Congress that is beholden to employers who have become dependent on low-wage, non-citizen labor.

Despite recent highly publicized "busts" like the janitorial workers at Wal-Mart, enforcement actions against employers have plummeted under Republican leadership. In 1999, the federal government initiated fines against 417 companies for employing illegal workers. In 2004, it issued fine notices to only three, according to the June 16 edition of the Washington Post.

You can pretty much date our current immigration problem to 1986. No, not because Elton Gallegly was elected to Congress that year, but because of Ronald Reagan's amnesty program — part of his larger campaign to bust American labor unions. He gave employers the green light to hire immigrants and encouraged them to stay on as year-round residents.

It worked. Unions now have just a fraction of their former clout in the workplace, and American wages have been spiraling downward for two decades. Unfortunately, unions were far more effective at keeping illegal immigrants out of the workplace than the Immigration and Naturalization Service or the employers.

Before you cast your vote in November, ask yourself this: In the 20 years Gallegly has been keeping his "firm stance" against illegal immigration, have things gotten better or worse? Doesn't it make sense that the Democratic Party, with its historic ties to American labor, would be more motivated to solve this problem than the party of the low-wage employers?

— John Johnson, Ventura

Leave a comment

Letters To The Editor
Letters to the Editor are published as they come in and are verified by our editorial staff. You may respond here to any and all letters published.