On Tuesday night, the Frontline television show examined the current dynamics behind the war in Afghanistan. The episode was appropriately titled "Obama's War." During the campaign, President Obama firmly opposed the war in Iraq and stated that Afghanistan was where America needed to place its focus. Since taking office, the war in Afghanistan has continued to drag on with no improvements. More troops were dispatched earlier this year, but General McChrystal is still asking for more. At eight years, this is becoming a no win situation.
The Frontline episode examined many interesting aspects of the war: widespread government corruption in Afghanistan, lack of support on behalf of Pakistan, and the inability to defeat the Taliban and al-Qaeda.
So back to the most basic question that we faced in Iraq: why don't we just cut and run?
And back to the most basic answer, because we can't.
By leaving the country while it is in such a weak state, we would allow the Taliban to easily regain control of part if not all of the country. When the Taliban were in power, they ruled with an iron fist and allowed no freedom. If we pull out and the Taliban regain control, the last eight years were a waste. There has been too much human sacrifice to just pack up and go home.
When can we say when though? The Soviets gave in after nine years.
As for further troop increase, I would advise the President against it. General McChrystal wants about 45,000 more troops to add onto the already 60,000 plus already there. That would be over 100,000 American troops to fight the Taliban. It could be seen as one last ditch effort before year nine. Such an increase would only draw more anti-American sentiment though. It seems that Bush's quagmire in Iraq has become Obama's quagmire in Afghanistan.









Obama has two wars:
1. to kill people in afghanistan
2. the war on the american private sector middle class
You miss the most important reason we must win in Afghanistan. If we fail, Pakistan will fall shortly thereafter and the terrorists will have their hands on a readymade nuclear arsenal along with the means to deliver it. That means we can't afford to let Pakistan fall even if we have to put troops in there against the will of Pakistan.
Let no one be fooled. The fight in Pakistan is over those bombs! Who do you want to win that fight, America?
For all of those Americans so anti-terrorist and yet so anti-Obama should realize the hypocrisy of their arguments. In supporting the war in Afghanistan, one supports the attempt (because success is never guaranteed) to bring peace and democracy to the Afghani people. In supporting the withdrawal of troops, you acknowledge the high probability of terrorist retaliation after our troops come home.
Daniel,
You have been promoted to field blogger covering Afganistan. Congradulations.
Joe, Have the Star buy the ticket and I will be there.
We want you to report on the war from a soldiers perspective. When is a good time to have a recruiter give you a call?
Anytime. Give me a call. 805-844-9486.
Hey I forgot. Army, Marines, Air Force any preference?
I will find the highest ranking officer I can.
Don't let your sons and daughters die in far off place for the taxes and tryanny guy, Barack Obama...Barack doesn't even have the courage to show you his birth certificate......