Login | Member Center | Contact Us | Site Map | Archives | Alerts | Subscribe to the paper

HomeBlogsThe Alpha State

« Barrooms, backrooms and living rooms |  Main  | Wal-Mart »

August 31, 2006

Survivor irony

CBS (in a desperate attempt to revive a failing reality show) announced this week that the “teams” on the new Survivor will be split along racial lines.

The response was immediate and predictable. The show is racist, bad for America and certainly bad for the races involved.

Two things that those with a sense of humor will find entertaining and ironic.

First, the groups decrying this racial spilt are all race specific groups; black, Latino and Asian caucus groups from New York’s City Council, the black group Project 21 and Hispanics Across America to name a few. I am always struck by the way race-based groups – with a straight and outraged face - attack anyone who does something based on race.

Second, none of the protestors or protesting groups are white, though whites have a “tribe” on the new show.

CBS has achieved their goal, invaluable amounts of free publicity and a very good shot at high ratings. Race based groups will get their air time and a fresh infusion of “outrage” money and very little else will change in this country because a minor television show thought it would be good TV to split teams up based on race.


Comments

I never understood why this was a big deal. On the contender the spilt the teams into east coast vs. west coast, there are battle of the sex shows, it is simply another way of grouping people. I for one think that it is a horrible idea, but no worse then any other reality tv, and no more racist then battle of the sexes is sexist.

Posted by: at September 1, 2006 07:44 AM

Great point that the critics of racial segregation (even on a tv show) often have created race-based organizations themselves.

I'd point to a second example of inconsistency as well: There's no outcry when the "tribes" on Survivor or based on sex or age....so why the sudden outrage when race becomes the factor?

Posted by: Steve at September 1, 2006 08:51 AM
Post a comment






Remember personal info?






Sponsored Links