Home › Blogs › The Alpha State
« California: The Alpha State – This Week in media | Main | $20 million reasons to pay attention »
April 02, 2007
Steinbeck and immigrants
For the umpteenth time, I am reading John Steinbeck’s Travels With Charley. It is my favorite book from my favorite author and I have yet to read the book without learning something new. For those who haven’t had the opportunity, it his account of a 3-month, 10,000 mile, 34 state trip around the country in a pickup truck (Rocinante) with his dog, Charley.
At one point in the trip, he is visiting Aroostook, Maine, which was one of the three great potato-raising areas in America (along with Idaho and Long Island) and discussing the immigrants (in this case French Canadian) who cross borders to harvest our food. Although the book was written 45 years ago, I was struck by the following passage….
“I’ve seen migrant crop-picking people around the country: Hindus, Filipinos, Mexicans, Okies away from their states. Here in Maine, a great many were French Canadians who came over the border for the harvest season. It occurs to me, just as the Carthaginians hired mercenaries to do their fighting for them, we Americans bring in mercenaries to do our hard and humble work. I hope we may not be overwhelmed one day by peoples not too proud or too lazy or too soft to bend to the earth and pick up the things we eat.”
On my radio show this week, Ward Connerly talked about the cultural devastation in the black community and the dearth of jobs available for young blacks and how it is a misnomer that they wouldn’t do the jobs that Mexican immigrants are doing. Steinbeck and Connerly are both bright men and if they’re both right….
Comments
I had left it unfinished for dramatic affect:-) However, if I was to finish it, it is the fear that we are destroying a part of America (black culture), while potentially setting ourselves up for a situation (11 million illegal immigrants, demanding "rights") that we are not equipped to deal with.
Posted by: Scott Harris at April 2, 2007 05:12 PMI will not like to put words in your mouth, but when you say "the jobs that Mexican immigrants are doing", are you talking about illegal Mexican immigrants only or do you include legal immigrants (Mexican and other groups from Latin America, Asia, the former Soviet Union, etc.) and/or proposed "guest" workers (as we had in the 40s, 50s and 60s)?
I still am not exactly sure that I understand exactly what you are saying here about "destroying a part of America (black culture)".
Between 1880 and 1920 when large number of Italians came and took lower paying jobs, did it displace or destroy the Irish in America? What about the Chinese immigrants (particularly in California) versus other European immigrant workers? Did it destroy the place and culture of these other groups who struggled on the bottom rungs of the social ladder? Looking at the history of American immigration, can you really say that?
Posted by: E.K. Hornbeck at April 2, 2007 09:15 PM


"and if they're both right . . ."
I am a bit slow this afternoon, so would you please finish your sentence, Scott? Exactly what is it that you almost said?
Posted by: E.K. Hornbeck at April 2, 2007 03:40 PM